metime
Research Start reading
metime Research · Where Pornhub Users Went · November 2026

Pornhub blocked? Searches went to a rival site, hardly erotica

In 24 states where Pornhub left or began checking ID, its Google search share fell 68% in six months; a rival video site rose 59%, erotica site Literotica 6%.

Analysis: metime Research · 11 November 2026 metime Research is the data desk of metime, an app that uses AI to write interactive romance fiction for adults.

Key findings

  • Six months after Pornhub left, its share of state searches was down 68%; a rival site's was up 59%.→
  • Searches for the erotica site Literotica rose about 6%, and rose in 21 of 24 states.→
  • Run a year before each exit, when nothing changed, the same test finds nothing: −1% for Literotica.→
  • Literotica's rise held for a year but shrank (+3%); the rival site's grew to +66%.→
  • VPN searches rose 17%; fan-fiction sites, Wattpad and Kindle did not move.→

We compared Google searches in 24 states for the 26 weeks before and after Pornhub left (in Louisiana, began checking ID) with the same weeks in 12 states with no law. Find your state. Laws took effect in West Virginia and Iowa in June and July 2026, the newest of the 27 state laws we tracked.

Finding 1 · Google searches · 24 states

Most of the searching moved to a rival video site

Six months after Pornhub left a state, Pornhub's share of the state's Google searches was down 68%. Searches for the rival site XVideos were up 59%, and for VPNs 17%.

Use this chart

We call this the exit effect: the change in a site's share of a state's Google searches in the 26 weeks after Pornhub left, measured against the same weeks in 12 states with no law. Across the 24 states the median exit effect was −68% for Pornhub (95% range −73% to −65%), +59% for XVideos (+54% to +68%) and +17% for VPNs (+11% to +21%). Searches for another big video site, xHamster, fell 30%.

Pornhub's share fell in all 24 states, and searches for the rival site and for VPNs rose in 21 and 23 of them. Pornhub itself said in its 2025 Year in Review that phone use in the United States dropped from 92% to 84% of its traffic, likely because of the age-verification laws; that is the company's own explanation.

The catchThese are shares of Google searches, not visits or people, and Google Trends samples its data. In Arizona, South Dakota and Wyoming, searches for the rival site fell too; we did not check whether it also left those states.

Finding 2 · Google searches · placebo test

Literotica rose about 6%: small, but it passed the placebo test

Searches for the erotica site Literotica rose a median 6.2% in the six months after Pornhub left (95% range 3.6% to 9.4%). They rose in 21 of the 24 states.

Use this chart

To check that this was not a trend already under way, we ran the same test a year before each exit, when nothing had changed. For Literotica it gives −1.1%. We also gave each of the 12 comparison states the exit dates of the 24 states, 288 runs in all; their median for Literotica was −0.2%.

Searches for the word “erotica” rose too, by 7% (range 2% to 17%). Other reading did not move: fan-fiction sites (Archive of Our Own, Wattpad) and Kindle stayed within 1.5 points of zero, and “smut” within 2.5, none clearly different from no change.

The catchA small effect on a share of searches, and a search is not a visit. The exit week comes from the data: it is the week Pornhub's search share fell hardest, which matched the law's start date in most states (see state by state).

Finding 3 · 13, 26 and 52 weeks

The shift to Literotica lasted a year, but shrank

Literotica searches were up 5.0% at three months, 6.2% at six months and 2.8% at a year after Pornhub left.

Use this chart

The rival site's gain grew over the same year: +54% at three months, +59% at six and +66% at a year. Pornhub's share kept falling: −65%, −68%, then −72%.

The catchThe number of states changes with the window: 25 at three months (Iowa's exit is too recent for longer tests), 24 at six months and 23 at a year (Wyoming drops out too). At a year Literotica rose in 19 of 23 states.

Finding 4 · State by state

Every state in the test, with its exit date

Literotica's biggest six-month rises were in Montana (+35%), South Carolina (+16%), South Dakota and Arizona (+14%), and Florida and Kentucky (+12%).

We set each exit date from the data, not from the statute: it is the week with the sharpest four-week fall in Pornhub's share of the state's searches. We then checked it against the date the state's law took effect. In 21 of the 24 states the two fall within three weeks of each other. In Texas the exit came in March 2024, when Pornhub was reported to have shut down there after a court fight over the law; in Indiana it came two days after an appeals court let the law take effect; Wyoming's came nine months after its law, and we cannot explain it.

The two groups of states differ politically. 23 of the 24 exit states voted for Donald Trump in 2024, against 3 of the 12 comparison states (Pennsylvania, Michigan and Wisconsin). The comparison states are also larger. The test compares each state with its own past, which handles fixed differences between states, but not a trend that runs differently in red and blue states over the same weeks.

Change in each search's share of the state's Google searches against 12 comparison states, 26 weeks after the exit unless marked. Single-state figures are noisy, especially in small states; the 24-state median is the headline figure. Wyoming's +114% is left out of every summary line as unreliable.

Download the data: every state (CSV)All searches and windows (CSV)

What earlier research found, and what is new

The move to rival video sites and VPNs is already documented. Lang and colleagues (SAGE, early 2026) found Pornhub searches fell 51% where the laws took effect, with a shift to sites that do not check ages and to VPNs. The Cato Institute reported gains for XVideos and XNXX, and VPN surges were reported in Florida and Missouri.

What is new here: the move to written erotica, which we found no earlier coverage of; a placebo test run a year before each exit; the same test at three months, six months and a year; a state-by-state table with exit dates set from the data and checked against the laws; and the finding that fan-fiction sites, Wattpad and Kindle did not move.

What did not hold up

“Searches for erotic stories rose 21%”

The figure is real but too noisy to quote: its 95% range runs from 6% to 66%, and at a year its placebo is +9.5%. We lead with Literotica instead.

“Searches for spicy books and AI girlfriends fell”

Both were already falling a year before the exits (placebo −12% and −13%), so these are trends that were under way, not effects of the exits.

Wyoming's +114% for Literotica

Wyoming's Google figures are unstable and its exit came nine months after its law, so we leave it out of every summary line.

Ohio and West Virginia as exit states

Ohio's law took effect in September 2025 but our data show no fall in Pornhub searches there. West Virginia's fall (31%) was below our 35% threshold. Neither is counted.

What we could not test

Visits and reading

Google searches show what people looked for, not what they visited or read, and many people type a site's address without searching.

Literotica's own age checks

We did not check whether Literotica asks for ID in any of these states.

Louisiana

Pornhub did not block Louisiana. It kept the site open behind the state's ID check, which began on 1 January 2023. We count Louisiana as an exit state because Pornhub's search share there fell 39% when the check began.

How we did it

Searches

Weekly Google Trends data for each state and for the US, late December 2021 to November 2026, for 15 searches: Pornhub, XVideos, xHamster, VPN, Literotica, erotic stories, erotica, smut, Archive of Our Own, Wattpad, Kindle, romance novels, spicy books, AI girlfriend and AI porn. For each state we used the search's share in the state relative to its share in the US.

Exit dates and states

The exit week is the week with the sharpest four-week fall in Pornhub's share of the state's searches. A state counts as an exit state when that fall was more than 35% and the state had an age-verification law. Law dates come from ageverificationlaws.com and stateofsurveillance.org, compiled for 27 states.

The exit effect

For each state and search, the change in the average of the 13, 26 or 52 weeks after the exit week against the same number of weeks before, leaving out two weeks either side, minus the same change in the 12 comparison states: California, New York, Illinois, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Washington, Colorado, Minnesota, Wisconsin, Oregon, Massachusetts and New Jersey. We report the median across states, with a 95% range from resampling the states 4,000 times.

Placebos

The same test with every exit date moved 52 weeks earlier, when nothing had changed (22 states at six months; Utah and Louisiana lack the earlier data). And the same test run on each comparison state at each exit state's date, 288 runs per search.

Limits

  • Shares of Google searches, sampled by Google, not counts of people or visits.
  • Exit and comparison states differ politically and in size.
  • Colorado, a comparison state, shows a 25% fall in Pornhub's search share in April 2026 that we cannot explain; it may weaken the comparison for the latest exits.
  • Single-state figures are noisy.

Sources

Method notes and the analysis script are available to journalists on request.

For journalists

Cite this study

Source: metime Research, "Where Pornhub Users Went", November 2026, https://metime.ink/research/where-pornhub-users-went/

In copy: “according to an analysis by metime Research”. Please link to this study page, which is safe for work, rather than the metime home page.

The charts and data on this page are free to use under CC BY 4.0, with credit to metime Research and a link to this page. Each chart has a “Use this chart” button with an embed code and a PNG, and the state look-up gives a ready line for any of the 24 states. The state table is the dataset: download it (CSV).

Copy-ready lines

Press: hello@metime.ink Analysis: metime Research
About metime

metime, which publishes metime Research, is an app that uses AI to write interactive romance fiction for adults: metime.ink. The analysis was done in-house by the team that owns and runs metime.

More studies